Skagit County is Mandated by Law to Hire More Public Defenders

By Rebecca Peck

Currently, statewide public defenders’ caseloads continue to be much too large to provide quality due process. For years now Skagit County chose, just like most other counties, to not fully fund its constitutional duty to ensure adequate counsel. Currently and historically, County Commissioners are directly in charge of implementing the 5th and 6th Amendments via funding of the Public Defenders Office. This constitutional responsibility is the most foundational duty that our Commissioners have.

The alleged reason for violating defendants’ constitutional rights is the expense and lack of funding. Therefore, a new State law enacted this year lowers the caseload limits. Over a 10-year period, caseload limits must phase down to 120 cases per public defender for misdemeanors. According to reporting by the Skagit Valley Herald in June 2025, this will reduce caseloads by about two-thirds.

Impact of the New Law

Public Defenders Office Director, Jeri Chavez, notes that for 2026, year one of the phase in, Skagit public defender caseloads are well below the current 372 cap on cases per public defender for misdemeanors, as they are for felony caseloads. She expects that to be the case in 2027 as well when caseload limits reduce to 344 for misdemeanors. Felony cases are weighted differently depending on the complexity of the case and therefore the caseload limits are lower.

Because the Washington Supreme Court chose to give counties 10 years to come into compliance, Skagit now has 9 years to get to 120 caseload level. Looking at the decade timeline, it may seem comforting that Skagit Courts are currently under an arbitrarily set maximum caseload number of 372 for 2026, while ignoring the fact that this still means Skagitonians are not getting properly funded due process.

23 More Public Defenders Needed

Due to the new law, Skagit County is projected to need 23 more public defenders to get caseloads down to where legal representation is not compromised. Those future 23 public defenders, with their maximum caseload of 120 each, will see a total of 2,640 defendants. That means that without adding those additional attorneys, a minimum of 2,640 people at any given time could be denied a rigorous defense. That is a lot of Skagitonians being denied their constitutional rights to adequate legal counsel and due process.

Chavez further notes, “Per State Supreme Court Order, in addition to being below the maximum shown in the [implementation] chart, the county also has to make progress every year toward lessening caseloads, and cannot go backwards, even if the number is less than the listed maximum for that year.”  

History of Due Process

The right to legal counsel is a core American principle that predates the establishment of American independence. The first right to counsel law was passed in Rhode Island in 1660. 
In our Constitution the 5th Amendment states that no person will be “deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law”. The 6th Amendment further spells out our rights to a fair trial:


 The right to be informed of the nature and cause of criminal charges
 The right to a speedy and public trial by impartial jury
 The right to confront and compel witnesses
 The right to assistance of counsel


Notably, the US Supreme Court declared in 1984, “Of all the rights that an accused person has, the right to be represented by counsel is by far the most pervasive, for it affects his ability to assert any other rights he may have.”

Local History of Due Process

In 2013 the American Civil Liberties Union won a lawsuit against the cities of Mount Vernon and Burlington because of the lack of enough public defenders. At the time the recommended caseload was 400 per public defender. The cities contracted just 2 public defenders, one full time, one at 40%. Their caseload was approximately 1,000 defendants each. They spent an average of 1 hour total on a defendant’s case. It was easy for the ACLU to show that the cities deprived indigent defendants of their 6th Amendment right to the assistance of counsel.

It should be noted that the Cities contracted the Judges for their Municipal Courts from Skagit County District Court. The staggeringly huge caseloads were not reined in by our local judges. It took the ACLU lawsuit to start to make changes in caseloads in our municipal courts.

Why are the Public Defenders caseloads so high?

The court system has 2 prongs, the prosecution and the defense. The huge caseloads of the public defenders happens because the prosecution prong is able to manage and file many more cases than the defense prong can handle. That shows that while the Prosecutor’s Office is amply funded, the Public Defenders Office is currently underfunded.

Counties believe the State should fund public defenders

Washington State Counties sued the State in 2023 to get the State to fully fund county public defenders. Counties have carried the burden of funding their public defenders for over 100 years, with Washington State only contributing approximately 3%. Notably, more than half of the other states fully fund public defenders. The Washington State Association of Counties says the goal of the lawsuit is to create a mandate for the state to fully fund public defense, similar to the state Supreme Court’s McCleary decision on education. The State argues that the counties are in charge of their local public safety policies, thus the county creates the need and should pay for public defenders. (Washington is among the bottom of states in public defense funding | Cascade PBS). The lawsuit is in process.

Meanwhile, both the State and Counties seem to enjoy finger pointing at each other while knowingly not meeting their Constitutional duty of providing due process. This means more impoverished people are found “guilty” and end up in jail, direly impacting their lives and costing taxpayers more in jail costs and social services. We cannot continue to deny due process for our neighbors while we wait for State funding that may or may not arrive.

How to fund Due Process in Skagit County Now

There are two ways that Skagit County can meet the constitutional requirement as well as the new legally required reduced public defender caseloads.

The first way is to fully fund the 23 more public defenders needed to reduce caseloads. This means nearly tripling the budget for the Public Defenders Office. Currently the County is in a budget crunch, so it will be hard to find the funds for this.

The second alternative is to reduce the funding for the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office and/or law enforcement. Those are the two choices. Either strengthen the defense prong to handle the flow from the prosecution side or diminish the flow from the prosecution side enough that the defense prong can handle the caseload. What is NOT a legal option is to continue to knowingly violate Skagitonians’ constitutional right to due process.

Use all of HB2015 tax for Public Defenders

A new tax revenue option was made available to the counties when the lowered caseload law was enacted. House Bill 2015 allows the county to enact a 0.1% tax that can be used for hiring public defenders. The funds last for 3 yrs and only pay 75%, while Skagit County has to pay 25%. In fact, House Bill 2015 specifically allows the funds to be used for public defenders because they know the Counties need funds for this. Therefore, this is a perfect way for Skagit County to pay for jobs that Skagit County is legally required to fund. For this reason, House Bill 2015 Revenue should all go towards the Public Defenders Office.

However, currently the County has chosen to use these funds to hire additional law enforcement positions, positions that are not mandated, rather than focus on solving the lack of due process. This new revenue stream should not be used to fund traditional law enforcement positions.

Cut the Prosecutor’s Budget

Another way to increase funds to the Public Defenders Office is to cut 1 million from the Prosecutor’s Office. This works out to about 4-5 less prosecutors. The downsizing of the Prosecutor’s Office will directly impact the Public Defenders Office by reducing the inflow of cases, which will allow public defenders more time to spend on a client’s case, thus getting closer to providing due process to all indigent clients.

That same 1 million in funds should then be added to the Public Defenders Office budget. This would pay for about 4-5 new public defenders. Redistributing funds from the Prosecutor’s office to the Public Defenders Office is an efficient cost savings method to quickly enhance due process while also taking a huge step to fulfilling the mandated smaller caseloads.

Shortage of Attorneys in Skagit County

Overall, Skagit County has a serious shortage of defense attorneys, both private and public. Due to the new reduced caseload law every county will soon be hiring a lot of new public defenders. The demand for public defenders is going to skyrocket, which likely means competitive wages will also go up. From a financial perspective this is going to impact budgets and Skagit County should be proactive about filling these positions as soon as possible.

Due Process is foundational to protecting Democracy

We are living in historic and radical times. There is nothing more radical than destroying the Constitution. Nationally, the current attack on the right to due process, a blatant undermining of the Constitution, coupled with policies removing supports for poor people, means more people are at risk of needing the protection of their core rights. As the Constitution is being shredded by radicals, we must take strong decisive actions to protect it.

What price do Skagitonians put on our Constitutional Rights and Democracy?

It will be costly to fully fund the Public Defenders Office. However, without protecting due process, there is serious risk to our Democracy. We should strengthen our court system by shoring up due process for all defendants. Protecting due process is protecting our Democracy. We should ask the Skagit County Commissioners to remember their Oath of Office in which they swore to support the Constitution and then do exactly that by fully funding the Public Defenders Office.

If caseloads should be capped at 120 in 10 years, it also means caseloads should only be 120 now. Based on current caseload numbers, the current loads are approximately double the goal of 120. The reality is caseloads should be 120 now, but the law gave counties a decade to get there. Skagit County Commissioners are choosing this year, and likely next year, to not begin to rectify this unconstitutional lack of due process. That means that many, many people, currently and for the next several years, are not getting full due process because the public defenders are overloaded.

The Commissioners hold the purse strings to fund this core constitutional principle. We should urge them to help protect our Democracy by proactively and significantly increasing the budget for the Public Defenders Office. We cannot wait, we must protect due process now. Protecting due process at the local level is protecting our Democracy.

If you’re worried about how to protect and strengthen our Democracy, tell our leaders to fully fund due process in Skagit County. Change starts at the local level. This is your chance to help Skagit County shine as a beacon of Democracy.

Ron Wesen: [email protected]
Peter Browning: [email protected]
Joe Burns: [email protected]

Rebecca Peck is a retired social systems worker who has lived in Skagit since her teens. She wants to help build equality and justice for all in our valley. Please join her and comment about the issues you care about to the Skagit County Commissioners during the weekly Public Comment period, usually Tuesday 11:30am.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *